Oreo Stuffed Brownie Cookies Recipe

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Fudgy brownie cookies with crackly tops, gooey insides, packed with chocolate chips, and stuffed with an Oreo. These cookies are simple to make (starting with a mix!), taste simply sinful, and are so much fun!

I’ve mentioned before (oh, a million times and counting) that I ADORE brownie mix cookies. So, yes. Here’s another recipe to add to the pile. And there are more coming, so I really, really, hope I’m not the only one in love here. (And  if you haven’t tried the base recipe yet, you MUST!)

Remember when the internet exploded with these Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies? And then a few months after that, remember how these Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie & Oreo Brownies were everywhere you looked?

As a society, we LOVE stuffing Oreos in our cookies and brownies. And we love making cookies into brownies and brownies into cookies and making brownies and cookies into other things like pies and ice cream.

And I’m a sociologist. So I know what I’m talking about here. (For realsies. I have a degree and everything).

So making a brownie that’s a cookie and stuffed with an Oreo is really just the natural societal progression of things in my professional opinion.

Ok, so like I said– I used my basic brownie mix cookie recipe here. I love it because it holds up like a cookie, but the insides are incredibly fudgy just like your favorite brownies. And the crispy, crackly tops are like the cherry on top.

Or Oreo in the middle. Same diff.

Now here’s where things get real: the Oreo.

I’ve tried the Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie, and it’s good. But I was a little disappointed that the Oreo stayed so hard. It’s a little distracting when you’re eating the cookie. Not so in these brownie cookies! Remember how these have super fudgy insides? When they bake up, those fudgy insides soften the Oreo turning them into soft pillows of fudgy-brownie-Oreo goodness.

It is literally Oreo-stuffed-anything perfection.

And is it just me, or are the orange Halloween Oreos the very best ones??

By the way, have you visited me over on eBay yet? I write How To articles and Recipe Roundups twice a week over there. And in case you’ve been wondering… this is apparently what organized people do every day (and it doesn’t include eating cookies, like I had hoped).

Here are plenty more cookie recipes.

Try my Chocolate Dipped Toffee Chip Cookies next.