Bread Machine Yeast vs Instant Yeast: What’s the Difference?

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Have you ever wondered what the difference is between bread machine yeast vs instant yeast? Well, let’s go over it. The two yeast types are not entirely different from one another because they both work equally well when baking a loaf of fresh-baked bread or doughnuts.

While bread machine yeast vs instant yeast can be very similar in consistency, there can be some noticeable differences.

What Are The Types Of Yeast Out There?

There are two different types of yeast to consider: active dry and instant. Active Dry Yeast is the most common type, but in some cases, you can use Instant Yeast as well (with a few limitations).

If you are gluten-free, vegan, or have other dietary restrictions and cannot find a substitute for yeast that will fit your needs, It is recommended to add it to the recipe as near to what is called for so that you may not alter the amount too much.

If you’re using instant yeast, be sure to use 25% more active dry yeast and dissolve it in less water.

A lot of people believe that active yeast has a fuller flavor profile than instant yeast (rapid-rise yeast) because it takes longer for the dough to rise. This can be challenging, but if you plan and know what you’re doing then this will not pose any problems.

Active Dry Yeast vs Instant Yeast

When you first start baking bread, it can be difficult to know which type of yeast is best. It turns out that they both work equally well and should blend seamlessly with the other ingredients in your recipe.

When it comes to instant yeast vs. active dry, you’ll need to consider the difference between instant and dehydrated yeast. Two primary differences will help you make your decision.

For starters, different bread machine recipes or active dry recipes need varying quantities of ingredients. For example, bread machine yeast has finer granules and reduces prep time.

You can use instant yeast to create bread without having to worry about proofing or hydrating the dough. Likewise, you have standard dry active yeast that requires water mixed in before it is ready for baking and takes longer than the instant starter.

Bread Machine Yeast

Bread machine yeast is a catch-all term for several types of baker’s yeasts you can use in bread machines. Click To Tweet

The main purpose of this ingredient is to make the quick-rising dough in your special bread machine. Bread machine yeast does not have a strong flavor profile, but it’s also less expensive than other types of yeast that require more time for rising.

Bread machine owners have an option to buy this type of yeast, which is highly marketed because it speeds up the baking process. It’s bound to be less flavorful than bread that takes a longer time in rising but who has time for patience?

What Exactly Is Instant Yeast?

The yeast you use for your bread is an important decision. Instant yeast, also known as “rapid rise yeast” or “quick-rise yeast” will work well with recipes that require a fast rising time. This type of dough can be mixed by hand and does not need to proof before baking.

Instant dry yeast is different from active dry because it contains ascorbic acid. This ingredient works with the live cells to condition dough, improving its elasticity and making your bread rise better. Click To Tweet

Fresh Yeast

This type of yeast is soft and moist, but it’s not as versatile. Dry Yeast on the other hand preserves moisture by pressing and drying them which makes dry yeast dormant until you mix with water.

Fresh yeast is also highly perishable and needs to be refrigerated, while dry yeast has a longer shelf life of about one year. Unless the package is opened, it doesn’t need to be refrigerated.

How to Replace Dry Yeast with Fresh Active Yeast

One 0.6-ounce cake of yeast is equal to a packet of dry yeast, while two ounces is equivalent to three packets of dry yeast. Follow the advice on the container for what type of yeast you are substituting.

How to Replace Different Kinds of Yeast

When it comes to commercial baking, measuring is key. Most home bakers don’t need to change the amount of liquid they use because yeast makes up such a small part of their recipe.

• One packet of active dry yeast is about the size of a nickel and contains 2 ½ teaspoons worth.
• If you’re looking to substitute instant rise yeast for active dry, use 25% less of the former than what is called for in your recipe.
• One cup of cake yeast is the equivalent to one and a half teaspoons instant or two tablespoons active dry.

How To Make Sure Your Yeast Is Working

To test the viability of yeast, add a cup of warm water and 2 ¼ teaspoons. If after 10 minutes it rises close to halfway in the container then you can bake with this mixture because there is still enough live yeast present. This test is called proofing.

If you don’t want to go out and buy a yeast testing kit, the old-fashioned way of telling if your yeast is alive still works. Just dissolve sugar in warm water and wait for it to bubble. If bubbles form on top of the mixture as the sugar breaks down into carbon dioxide, then that means that there are active yeast floating around.

Carbon dioxide and alcohol are by-products of the chemical reaction taking place during proofing.

Measurements Of Yeast

Yeast is a key ingredient for bread making. In most cases, you will need to use one teaspoon of the powdered product per cup of flour used in your recipe. If a packet or cake of yeast is mentioned, it means that there are 2 ¼ teaspoons worth inside, and if only 1 cube (2 tsp) is called for then 4 cubes would be needed.

Making The Most Of Proper Storage

Yeast can be stored in a cool, dry place like the pantry or refrigerator. Click To Tweet

However, exposure to oxygen and humidity will decrease yeast activity over time. Yeast should not be frozen as it destroys some of its delicate nutrients.

One of the worst things you can do to your yeast is leave it open and exposed after opening. The air will cause the cells in your jar or pack to break down, which then ruins all that wonderful flavor loved about bread and doughnuts.

Once you’ve sealed the ingredients in their container, they can either be frozen or refrigerated. Dry yeast is beneficial for up to four months if it’s been stored in a fridge and six months if it has been put into a freezer.

Does Active Dry Yeast Work in Bread Machines?

Bread Machine Yeast is designed to hydrate easily in the dough, while Active Dry Yeast may not be as effective. Your bread machine yeast must have vitamin C because it promotes good loaf volume and structure. Click To Tweet

What Does Yeast Proofing Mean?

Yeast is just an ingredient in bread. To make it work, you need to rehydrate the yeast before using it.

Adding water and waiting for the dough to rise is pretty easy. The only catch is that you need some time.

With instant yeast, you can make the dough and put it in the oven right away. But with active yeast, you need to let your dough rise twice before baking,

Dry yeast, while great for some recipes like cookies and quick breads that don’t require the dough to rise overnight in a warm place, is not ideal when it comes to traditional yeasted baking. The trick with dry yeast is knowing how much you need— if you use too little then your final product will be dense or have a hard crust on top.

You Knead To Get Baking

With bread machine yeast vs instant yeast, two types of instant yeast can be used in bread machines. One is called “bread machine” and the other “instant dry active yeast.” Both make baking easy, but there isn’t a significant difference between them.