Nutter Butter S’mores posted by Something Swanky Pin Share Tweet Email SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Ok. So I didn’t actually plan on making another S’mores recipe this week. I didn’t. I swear. And I really didn’t plan on posting a second post in one day– every decent blogger knows it’s just good sense to space out your posts. But I just couldn’t stop myself. I have to tell you about this recipe right now. After allowing myself one S’mores recipe, the flood gates were opened,and I just haven’t been able to stop thinking S’MORES. And you know how I get going on a theme and just. can’t. stop. (#monstercookies, #redvelvet, #girlscoutcookies) Right now, everything looks like a gigantic toasted marshmallow to me. It’s like I’m some kind of addict. And as I passed by the Nutter Butters at Walmart, inspiration struck. These are your new favorite S’mores. Seriously. Out of control good. And when I say “out of control,” I do mean out of control. 3 WW points a pop really adds up after you’ve eaten your third or fourth or eleventh one! But the heart wants what it wants, eh? You’re all intelligent folks, so I won’t bother with a recipe, just photos. I’ll just mention that I used my oven to do a quick broil-toast on the marshmallows. Please visit my Party Page for a more complete index of Link Parties. If you host a regular link party, please add it to my Party Page!
My brother introduced me to the idea of replacing the grahams with cookies! I have never tried this before though! Reply
Ever since I saw Shelly’s post about smores…it’s all I can think about too!!! My brain is going smore’s crazy…I have like 9 different ideas floating around in there!!! Nutter Butter smores…genius:-) Reply
I think you’ve converted me to a S’mores lover after this. PB, marshmallow, chocolate and cookies? Yes, I think I am officially a S’mores girl. Camping though… I’ll need more convincing 🙂 Reply
I’ve never heard of Nutter Butters but they look delish. I’m feeling kinda left out with all these goodies you have over there, pah! -Lisa.Sweet 2 Eat Baking Reply
Wow. I’ve used Reese’s PB Cups in place of Hershey’s, but replacing the graham crackers… that hadn’t occurred to me. I almost wish I hadn’t of seen this! Reply
I bet these are delicious! I love nutter butters but we are nut free home (since my kids are allergic) and I crave things with peanut butter constantly!!!! I may have to try these when we don’t have the kids one night! Found you on Lil Luna party! Amberhttp://www.recipeswelove.net Reply
I love this S’mores idea and would love for you to share it on our Kitchen Fun & Crafty Friday link party that I just posted! http://kitchenfunwithmy3sons.blogspot.com/2012/04/kitchen-fun-and-crafty-friday-link_26.html Reply
Smart idea! I love nutter butters! 🙂 Stopping by from Grateful Belly’s linky.~Amberdessertnowdinnerlater.blogspot.com Reply
I can imagine the taste of these! I’m sure they’re amazing. I have a list of a million things that one could make with nutter butters, but I’m in Canada, where they are not sold. It kills me every time I see something like this. Now I’m craving them! Ahh! I may have to take a trip to the states very, very soon!I would love if you came and shared with my readers http://rhapsodyofcacophony.blogspot.ca/2012/04/pin-ed-it-made-it-party-0427.html Reply
