Strawberry Cheesecake Easy Ice Cream Recipe posted by Something Swanky Pin Share Tweet Email Jump to Recipe SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. If you’re a fan of 2-ingredient ice cream, you’re going to looooooove this. And even if you’re not, I think you’ll want to give this recipe a try. For starters, the cheesecake ice cream “base” is unreal. The most common way of making 2-ingredient ice cream involves mixing together a can of sweetened condensed milk and 2 cups of whipped cream (or, for us lazies, cool whip). To create a (spot on, by the way) cheesecake taste, I also added cream cheese, butter, lemon juice, and vanilla. I wanted to create a graham cracker crust swirl, obviously. But, it seems, graham crackers no longer reside in my pantry. Fortunately, Golden Oreos do. Oh. yes. I. did. Instead of grahams, there is a fabulous swirl of Golden Oreo crust in the Cheesecake ice cream. And it only gets better from here… The coup de grâce to this whole ice cream scene is Lucky Leaf Strawberry Pie Filling. And ohmygosh, ittastessooooooooogoooood! Seriously. And it’s ridiculously compatible with ice cream. ….like, maybe even more so than with pie. Yeah. I went there. But really– that strawberry pie filling is the perfect consistency to freeze. It doesn’t get all ice-y (like my homemade sauce would if it were frozen in ice cream). Instead, it’s still a perfectly decadent and gooey consistency when frozen. So you won’t be chipping away at it with the ice cream scoop, and it’s not breaking any teeth when you try to eat it. Plus– since it’s canned, it’s already at room temperature, so it’s ready to go into the ice cream when you’re ready for it to go in! Moral of the story: if you’re looking for a creamy and decadent ice cream to serve up to all of your sweeties this Valentine’s day (or any day!), this is it ♥. Continue to Content Strawberry Cheesecake Easy Ice Cream Print Ingredients 1 - 14.5 oz can sweetened condensed milk 1 - 8 oz. tub Cool Whip 1 - 8 oz brick of cream cheese, softened 1/4 cup butter, softened 1 tbsp lemon juice 1 tsp vanilla extract 15 Golden Oreos (approximately half of a package) 1/4 cup butter, softened 1 - 21 oz can Lucky Leaf Strawberry Pie filling Instructions Use a hand mixer to beat together the sweetened condensed milk, cool whip, cream cheese, 1/4 cup butter, lemon juice, and vanilla extract in a large bowl until smooth. Set aside. In a food processor (or using whatever crushing method you prefer), process the Golden Oreos and 1/4 cup butter together until crumbly (should clump together though). Dump the crust "clumps" into the middle of the ice cream batter, don't stir. Pour the Lucky Leaf Strawberry Pie Filling over the crust "clumps." Use a large rubber spatula to gently fold the filling and crust into the ice cream batter. You should only need to use 2-3 strokes. You want swirls, and it's easy to over mix and combine everything instead if you're not careful. Pour mixture (this will mix it up a little bit more too) into a standard loaf pan and freeze for at least 4 hours (overnight is best). Notes about this Recipe: Don’t over mix, don’t over mix, don’t over mix! You could substitute graham crackers for the Oreos, but I don’t have a measurement to suggest. Just eyeball it– a little too much or too little won’t ruin it at all. My friends over at Lucky Leaf, who so generously provided me with samples of their pie fillings (and super cute baking-ware) to play with, want to send you some cute and yummy stuff too (shown below)! Simply leave a comment below to enter to win! I’ll choose a winner at random on February 28, 10pm. Be sure to connect with Lucky Leaf here: New! Website | Facebook | Pinterest | Twitter
OMG! My birthday is this upcoming Sunday and I plan to make this for my “birthday cake!” I can’t wait. It looks so yummy. Reply
Drooling!!! This looks beautiful and so delicious! And easy!!! I love the combo of cheesecake and strawberries! Blessings, Leslie Reply
OH MY, this looks so good and easy. I will be testing this out this weekend! Thank you for the recipe Reply
This is unreal…strawberries and Golden Oreo swirls in cheesecake ice cream? Yup, this is fabulous sounding! Reply
This sounds so good although I always prefer real whipping cream to cool whip. I love the idea of golden oreos! Reply
Looks so yummy! I think I might make this for my kids, they would love it! Thanks for the recipe! steph4575 at msn dot com Reply
I have been searching for a recipe like this one for a while now, thank you so much. I am doing this as soon as I can get to the grocery store! Reply
I happen to have leftover graham cracker crust in my fridge, so this would be a great use for it. Thanks for the delicious recipe idea & for introducing me to Lucky Leaf products! Reply
Oh my, this looks absolutely delightful, Ashton! I’ve been seeing recipes for this two-ingredient ice cream for awhile now, but I haven’t tried it yet. After drooling over this recipe, I definitely need to do it soon! Reply
YUM! Golden Oreos are so much better than graham crackers anyway. I recently made a similar recipe, but it was chocolate peanut butter. I think you win the more creative award on this one! 🙂 Reply
What have you just done? WHAT HAVE YOU DONE? I will totally never again fit into my pants. *sigh* Reply
This looks decedent and amazing! My boyfriend loves Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream but I LOVE that you used Golden Oreo’s!What a fabulous idea 🙂 Reply
Pillsbury posted your lemon meringue dip recipe and I just had to see for myself! Oh my what deliciousness! my husband’s birthday is Friday and I was searching for something good to make and I don’t know how I will ever narrow it down…thanks so much for all the goody ideas! Reply
Oh this ice cream looks heavenly! I would love to try it in blueberry, too. Amazing pics, Ashton 🙂 Reply
Girrrrrrrl! That is some illegal crack, right there! I’ll cover ya’ while you sneak out the back. Uh oh! I hear the sirens – ruuuuuunnnnn! Save the recipe! Oh wait, it’s NOT illegal? Oh, well…it should be…dadgum pictures makin’ me drool and thinkin’ of bad things! Tsk, tsk. You naughty woman. 😉 Reply
I cannot believe how pretty this looks! I just bought an ice cream machine and this is the first thing I am making! Thanks for this recipe! Reply
This looks very good and simple. I love that I don’t need an ice cream maker to make it. My whole family loves ice cream and it sounds pretty versatile. I’m definitely going to try it!! Thanks for the recipe. Reply
LOVE this idea and recipe! Can’t wait to make it, but have never seen Strawberry pie filling in my store! Reply
I would love this prize! And just whipped up the ice cream…with Graham,s. Its in the freezer now! Reply
OMG! This looks amazing, I can’t believe how simple it is. I’m making this for my husband as a Valentines Day Surprise! Can’t wait to post back and tell you our reactions. My mouth is watering already, let’s hope I can wait. Reply
I am digging this ice cream! What a fantastic idea. ALso Strawberry cheesecakr… My all time favorite!!! Thanks for sharing and the giveaway! Reply
oh my gosh, this looks so absolutely delicious. have you ever made ice cream with an ice cream maker? i’m wondering how i can make this recipe with an ice cream maker, but the swirls probably won’t let it work right? oh well, looks easy enough. ps. i want to win. so cute. so yummy! Reply
My mom’s delicious cheesecake recipe calls for smashed vanilla creme cookies for the crust instead of graham crackers. It’s still my favorite cheesecake!! So this looks totally delicious to me. Thanks for the recipe! Reply
Hi, found this via Pinterest and am in Australia where we don’t have cool whip! Would the measurement for cool whip be the same if using whipped cream? Thanks, Lucy Reply
I am so excited to make this for my daughter’s first birthday!!! It’s going to go perfect with her strawberry owl cupcakes, thank you so incredibly much for this recipe!! Reply
This looks so good and you made it sound so easy to make. It’s the best of both worlds! Can’t wait to try it. Reply
I am so excited to try this out for my bf on valentines… he LOVES cheesecake and this will be perfect and less time comsuming than actually making a cheesecake! Thanks for sharing! Reply
ohsweetjesus – something else for me to LOVE!!! I’m in heaven – can’t wait to make this! Thanks….. Reply
WHY oh WHY have I not made my own ice cream yet? Ashton, I’m pinning this amazing recipe because I sit here literally drooling on my keyboard in strawberry cheesecake envy. I’m literally eating a strawyberry cremesicle lifesaver candy right now and let me tell ya… it does NOT compare. i.need.ice cream!!!!!! Reply
This ice cream looks delicious! I’ve never made my own ice cream before and this looks easy peasy! I will definitely be making this soon! Thanks for the great recipe! Reply
I have never made 2 ingredient ice cream. This looks so easy and delicious. I love how it is so versatile. Will have to try this! (without oreos or graham crackers) Reply
I love cheesecake and I love strawberries. Can’t wait to try this. I’m having trouble finding the strawberry pie filling but I won’t give up. Thanks for posting. faith Reply
How beautiful is this ice cream?!?!?! I could eat the picture! I need to make this soon! Cute giveaway too!! Reply
What an absolutely delicious sounding dessert! Going to the grocery store in the morning. I hope I can find Lucky Leaf strawberry pie filling, I will be disappointed if I can’t! Your post makes it sound amazing!!! Reply
WoW! Your cheesecake looks yummy! And how AWESOME would it be to win these products. keshakeke(at)gmail(dot)com Reply
This looks great!! I always use Lucky Leaf pie filling, but can’t seem to find strawberry in the stores. Will keep my eye out though because this looks like something my husband and kids would love!! Reply
hi Sara, just wanted to say i couldn’t find strawberry pie filling either..so i used frozen strawberries thawed and mashed down..added sugar to them and cooked o low until cooked down and thickened and continued on with the recipe. The results were wonderful..Good Luck : ) Reply
I love easy condensed milk ice cream recipes! This one looks great! Will definitely try it out soon. Reply
I was looking for a treat to take to work on Valentine’s Day, and I believe this is the winner! Reply
Going to make this afternoon soon as i return from the grocery store to get the needed items. I have Lucky Leaf raspberry pie filling in my pantry and will try that. YUM! Reply
Ok! As I wipe the ice cream off my lips and sticky fingers(Hint) I will have to say this is my most favorite ice cream. I usually have to go to Mayfield to get a double scoop cone but no longer.Almost like heaven in a freezer. Thank you for the recipe. Reply
I can’t wait to try this! I am always looking for ice cream recipes that do NOT require an ice cream maker. If this is as good as it sounds, I will make it for my daughter’s graduation party this June (Going to make it for Valentine’s day first). Reply
I’m not a huge strawberry fan, but this looks (and sounds) AMAZING!! This will be on my to do list this week. Reply
Wow, my kids will love to adorn our kitchen aprons and mix this up to surprise Daddy for Valentines day! Home-made treats from the kids make the best gifts. Thanks for the idea! Reply
I’ve never tried 2 ingredient ice cream, but this looks awesome! And I’d love to win your giveaway. 🙂 Reply
I love strawberry cheesecake icecream. I wonder if they have raspberry filling? Now to make that shopping list 😉 Reply
Finally found a reason to be happy for the February heat in Houston, and will definitely be making this for my quilting bee girls! Fantastic sounding recipe! Reply
This sounds SO good! I never knew ice cream could be so easy to make without a machine/gadget/something! I really want to try this!! 🙂 Reply
~Oh My!! I can’t wait to wrap my lips on this! Drooling!!This looks Delisssssh!! My Birthdays on the 17th & I’m making me this!!Thanks!! Reply
It’s looks so good! How I wish they sold those things in the Netherlands so that I could try to make it too! I might just have to start looking for replacements/substitutes! Reply
This looks fabulous! I look forward to trying it with gluten-free graham crackers and having a DELICIOUS dessert when I’m craving cheesecake! Thanks for the inspiration! Reply
this looks so fabulous… I am making this TONIGHT! Going to the store now to pick up the ingredients that I don’t have on hand. 🙂 Reply
Yum! I do believe this will he dessert for my special sweeties for Valentines dinner!! Thank you for sharing! Reply
looks so yummy! i can’t wait to try this recipe out. what could be better than cheesecake & strawberries? mmmm Reply
I have a quick question. Could I put it in a 9X13 pan and freeze that? How many would it serve? Reply
This recipe serves 6-8, depending on how much each person eats 🙂 I wouldn’t recommend a 9×13 pan unless you’re at least doubling the recipe, I’m afraid it might get too hard. But I’ve frozen this kind of ice cream in tupperware before, and that worked fine, as long as it wasn’t too shallow! Reply
Are you selling this reicpe as a download? http://www.listia.com/auction/8273603-strawberry-cheesecake-easy-ice-cream If you need to contact Listia moderators, try this: (347) 254-7842 complaint form http://help.listia.com/attachments/token/dnwmhgif0tchkbv/?name=NoCI.pdf Reply
Ice-cream recipes that don’t call for an ice-cream maker are a winner in my books, and strawberry cheesecake is a family favorite around here. Double win! Reply
Just made this ice cream. Probably the easiest thing I’ve made in a long time! It was even good before it was frozen! Reply
Oh my goodness….my daughter and are huge fans of strawberry cheesecake ice cream. We have tried every brand available at our local grocery store. Our favorite brand discontinued theirs and I have been on the hunt for two years for a new favorite! Thank you so much for this awesome post. We are absolutely loving it! Making another batch tonight!! This is by far our new favorite! Thanks again!! Reply
This looks awesome!! My sister in laws birthday is coming up, i’ll have to try this out… thanks!! (i love this font by the way… whats it called?) Reply
Totally making this for my daugher and grandson’s birthday which is on the same day next month. How Yummy is this?? Reply
OMG this looks so tasty! And perfect since I don’t have an ice cream maker!! Thank you for posting this!! Reply
I am having a pink party for my birthday and this is for sure the ice cream I will be serving!! I can’t wait! Looks great! Reply
This recipe looks absolutely amazing! I recently made some banana & peanut butter ice cream, so I’m all for trying this out! Love that you used the golden oreo’s! Reply
I lvoe Lucky Leaf Pie filling I use them all the time but haven’t tried the Strawberry, the ice cream looks yummy will be shopping for the strawberry lucky leaf today and making this icecream today! Thanks for sharing. Reply
This sounds AMAZING!!! Even though we are currently experiencing severe weather, actually our first THUNDER-SNOW…YIKERS, I’m STILL headed out to our nearby Walmart this very moment to pick up the LUCKY BRAND strawberry-pie filling right now, as it is THE only thing I’m missing! Wish me Luck… 😉 Reply
This looks FABULOUS! Thank you for sharing! I am very new to the blog world and love to see what’s out there. Your blog is beautiful! I would love to get your advice on anything! Hope we can be blog friends! – Brook Reply
My favorite ice cream of all time. Reminds me of my childhood in Door County, Wisconsin. Makes me smile! Reply
Oh, that looks amazing! What makes it even better is that I don’t need an ice cream maker! Going to try this real soon, thank you for sharing! 🙂 Reply
This will definitely be my next ‘take to work’ dessert!! I don’t know if I can wait til then, though! Reply
I tryed the Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream to be honest i didnt think it would have the flavor it does it was awsome. Will definetly be makeing this again Reply
I would like to make this ice cream, but I am not a fan of Cool whip- has anyone done it with whipped cream- just wondering if it will work the same??? Reply
Yep– you can use whipping cream, whipped! 2 cups of whipping cream to 1 can of sweetened condensed milk 🙂 Reply
It’s my birthday on Saturday and I will make this for dessert for me and 20 of my guests! Sounds spectacular. Reply
OMG! I’m definitely going to try this soon. Do you have any other easy ice cream recipes you can send my way? I think Mother’s Day will be the perfect reason to make this (for myself, of course), but I’d love to have something everyone else in my house that doesn’t like strawberries might also enjoy. Reply
I’m not a fan of strawberry but I imagine this would be AH-MAZ-ING with any Lucky Leaf pie filling. Holy deliciousness! Reply
Made this today using 2 cups of fresh, unsweetened whipped cream (just not coolwhip fan), no lemon juice (I was out) & crushed Pepperidge Farms Shortbread cookies. It was amazing!!! Thanks for an easy recipe w/o all the junk in store bought ice cream! Reply
This is amazing. I used strawberry cream pie filling because the store I frequent was out of the plain strawberry. Tastes absolutely wonderful. No more driving to DQ to get the strawberry cheese quake blizzard………love, love, love this! Reply
I made this over night for the 4th of July, had to try it first this morning, it is devine!!! I’ve been looking for an easy strawberry cheesecake ice cream recipe for a while, thanks so much for this one! Was thinking you could also use 1/2 strawberry pie filling & 1/2 blueberry pie filling for red, white & blue. And I bet this would also make an awesome ice cream cake or ice cream sandwiches! Reply
Having no ice cream maker, this caught my eye… along with the words “strawberry” and “cheesecake”. =D Made about 2 weeks ago and just finished it up a couple nights ago. DELICIOUS and easy!! I plan to try it with cherry sometime in the future. Thank you! Reply
Anyone that hasn’t tried this yet…do it!! OMG, BEST ice cream ever!! Only thing I did differently was to use choc oreos. Gonna try it with choc covered graham crackers next time. Seriously, I don’t think I will ever buy ice cream again! Reply
FYI… The person in the link below is using your pics/recipes as their own with no credit or link back to you. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=596980043699315&set=pb.539803642750289.-2207520000.1382729130.&type=3&theater Have a great day. Lynn ~ Southern With A Twist Reply
I just made this last night. OH MY GOSH! This is the best thing I have ever eaten. I didn’t let it sit that long before we ate it. It was soft and creamy. We just had more. It was frozen. I like it better soft. Could eat it all by myself. Next time I’m going to make blueberry. One question though. How can I make apple pie or pumpkin? Would eat this over real ice cream any day. I just found your site, and I love it. The best I have been to so far. Love it. Reply
Sounds absolutely awesome & I have a LOT of Birthdays coming up in March & April to try this and play with other flavors! SO looking forward to this, Thanks for sharing!! 🙂 Reply
`This looks great! Have you considered adding frozen strawberries too? Instead of graham crackers, I was also thinking maybe those vanilla wafers. Mmm… Reply
OMG!!! This has to be the MOST DECADENT ice cream I have ever heard of. Will be trying this just as soon as I can get to the store!!! Thanks for sharing. Reply
Thank you so much for this great recipe…I am so looking forward to making this…I had not idea you could make ice cream without an ice cream maker….my husband loooooves ice cream and it comes in handy as we live on a sailboat and do not have lots of room like i a kitchen in a house. woo hoo!! Thanks again Sister kaite Reply
Always looking for fast, simple, good recipe to take to meeting, friends, and this Delish! For sure a save! Reply
