Best Substitute for Balsamic Vinegar in Salads and More

SomethingSwanky is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Balsamic vinegar can transform any dish you make. Don’t be discouraged if you run out. There is always a substitute for balsamic vinegar that you can use instead.

These alternatives may not taste as good as balsamic, but they can be a great substitute for balsamic vinegar if you lack some.

We have provided more information on many of these options. We also discussed the ingredients that you will need to combine to make great balsamic vinegar substitutes.

What is Balsamic Vinegar (and How Does it Work)?

You will need to be familiar with the basics of balsamic vinegar and its taste to make a good substitute.

Balsamic vinegar is well-known for its distinctive flavor profile and rich color. Balsamic vinegar is a milder vinegar than some other types that can be quite acidic. It has a mild, full-flavored taste.

It is very sweet and comes from Italy. It is made from unfermented grape juice and is aged in wooden barrels. It is more expensive than other types of vinegar due to the way it is aged.

Balsamic vinegar has a distinctive taste so it is difficult to substitute in a recipe. However, it can be replicated in some ways.

What is Balsamic Vinegar Used for in Cooking?

Balsamic vinegar is a versatile ingredient in the kitchen. It is no surprise that it is used in so many recipes, including meats and fruits as well as herbs.

Balsamic vinegar is a great addition to chicken. Here are some other ways to cook with balsamic vinegar. Even if you only have nutritious canned beans, you can still make delicious treats and specialties with them.

Is Balsamic Vinegar Healthy?

When properly incorporated into your nutrition, balsamic vinegar can make a big difference in your health. It is safe for all diets and is considered a low-fat ingredient.

According to Medscape General Medicine journal, different types of vinegar, such as balsamic vinegar are beneficial in treating infections. ⁽²⁾

Medical News Today also includes important balsamic vinegar health benefits: 

• Lowers Cholesterol
• Improves digestion
• Anti-obesity properties
• Ideal for people with diabetes
• It has good skin effects
• Hypertension can be improved

Substitute for Balsamic Vinegar

Cider Vinegar, Sugar

Mixing cider vinegar and sugar is a great substitute. You will need half a teaspoon of sugar for every tablespoon of cider vinegar.

You can heat the sugar and vinegar together in a saucepan over medium heat for a few seconds to ensure that they are well mixed.

The mixture should not be brought to a boil. When the mixture is reduced, it will produce a balsamic vinegar-type glaze.

Although it won’t taste exactly like balsamic vinegar, the sweetness of sugar will offset the sharpness of cider vinegar. If you have both ingredients, it is a good substitution.

White Vinegar, Sugar

You can substitute white vinegar for any apple cider or red wines vinegar if you don’t have any. Other types of vinegar can be used, including rice vinegar, Chinese black vinegar, and cane vinegar.

White wine vinegar is more subtle than other types. It is not too strong and not too sweet. It is a great choice overall.

Mixing sugar and white vinegar requires you to add one part sugar to every four to five parts vinegar, depending on how sweet the balsamic substitute is.

The sugar won’t dissolve in the vinegar so heat the mixture for a few minutes to get it to dissolve completely.

Red Wine Vinegar, Maple Syrup

Red wine vinegar, which is similar to sugar and apple cider vinegar, can be used as a substitute for balsamic.

Red wine vinegar is a bit more similar to apple cider vinegar than balsamic and has a similar color.

Red wine vinegar has a more complex and tangier flavor than balsamic. However, if you add some sweetness to it, this can help to soften the taste. You must use the right amount of each ingredient.

Because maple syrup has a thicker consistency and a more balanced flavor, it is a great ingredient to add to red wine vinegar. It is already a syrup so you don’t have to heat it to get the ingredients to mix.

You will need to add one tablespoon maple syrup for every four parts red wine vinegar. You can add a little more if you prefer your balsamic substitute sweeter, but it will likely lose its tangy flavor and become too sweet.

Maple syrup can be substituted for honey if you don’t have it in your pantry. You can also use brown sugar in this recipe, but it will need to be heated to make it mix well.

Soy Sauce, Lemon Juice, and Molasses

These three ingredients may make you wonder if they could resemble balsamic vinegar, especially since soy sauce is so strong and distinctive.

These three ingredients make a great substitute for balsamic vinegar when combined.

Balsamic vinegar has a slight molasses-like taste, as we’ve already mentioned. This makes it possible to substitute molasses for balsamic vinegar.

Additionally, the color of the soya sauce and molasses are similar to balsamic vinegar, so the soy sauce is a good base. Mixing all these ingredients together creates a similar consistency.

Although you might think adding lemons is a good idea, lemons can be very acidic. Vinegar is acidic so you will need to add some acidity.

Lemons are a great choice because of this. Although they are bitter and sour, their taste is not overwhelming. Once the mixture has been added, you will not be able to taste the lemon flavor much.

You should aim to use equal amounts of each ingredient to make the balsamic substitution. However, you can adjust the amounts to suit your tastes.

A Final Thought

We hope you found this article useful. If you don’t have any balsamic vinegar, you can make it taste like it.

If you don’t have any other types, you can use lemon juice, lime juice, or sugar as an alternative. Although it is not a perfect substitute for balsamic vinegar, it will provide the right tangy taste for your recipe.